LOURDES – no quick fix

Is it just harmless fun or cashing in on people's gullibility?

Is it just harmless fun or cashing in on the gullibility of desperate people?

I find Lourdes disturbing.

It worries me that some people can be so credulous as to think that making a visit to a town in the south of France on Planet Earth, circling an undistinguished star on a remote arm of the Milky Way galaxy, will somehow bring them closer to the creator of the universe.

And it worries me to find myself scoffing at something which is apparently at the core of some people’s lives.

In 1858, Bernadette Soubirous, a young girl from a poor family, experienced a series of visions in the Grotto of Massabieille. A beautiful lady appeared to her eighteen times, promising her happiness ‘not in this life but in the next’, and counselling her to ‘pray for sinners’. These may not sound like original, earth-shattering revelations, but nevertheless many soon believed that Bernadette had a direct line to the Almighty.

A spring appeared in the grotto and thousands claim to have been cured of their ailments by its waters. In 2015, believers, penitents and their assistants still troop towards Lourdes to share a little St Bernadette magic.

While there is no charge for the water, the same can’t be said for the beautiful-lady-shaped bottles that are on sale in the numerous souvenir shops that have sprung up all over the town. You can also order holy water online in an attractive container from the Catholic Gift Shop. From $15.99. And you thought Perrier water was overpriced. Holy music plays on the website. Christ overthrowing the tables of the money-changers in the temple comes to mind.

If making a pilgrimage to Lourdes brings some people peace and inner happiness, I’m fine with that. If ailments are alleviated, it doesn’t matter if it’s due to divine intervention or a placebo effect.

But I do hate seeing false hope offered to the simple, the vulnerable and the desperate by charlatans and people profiting from peddling nonsense. There must be many who leave Lourdes a little disappointed, though they may not admit it to family and friends who have gone to the trouble and expense of getting them there.

Waiting by the cave.

Waiting by the cave.

I took a few photos of the church, with its surprisingly contemporary artwork…

The church at Lourdes.

Pilgrims or tourists like us?

Pilgrims or tourists like us?

Then we sprinkled a little holy water on any parts of our bodies that were giving us trouble. No miraculous cures this time. You have to truly believe for it to work.

Mevrouw T bought a very reasonably priced snow dome of St Bernadette. ‘No, it’s not for me, it’s for a friend.’

Finest quality souvenir: St Bernadette and the beautiful lady, made in China.

Finest quality souvenir: St Bernadette and the beautiful lady, made in China.


Filed under France

9 responses to “LOURDES – no quick fix

  1. At least the “Holy Post” at Coogee Beach doesn’t have a souvenir shop yet.

  2. Don’t mock, there is holy water in that snow dome.
    I have never been to Lourdes but I saw something similar in Corfu where pilgrims visit the church of St Spyridon and take pictures of afflicted parts of the body and leave them with him hoping for a cure.
    I had never heard of St Lawrence O’Toole so just looked him up.

  3. It is criminal that the church profits from people’s ill health and hope. I don’t think I could bring myself to visit this place.

  4. Peehaps it’s because of my Catholic childhood, Richard, but my Achilles tendinitis was cured by Lourdes water when we visited. Admittedly, the pain of the tendinitis lasted for a year or so after the cure and only disappeared after much physio and exercise, but it was definitely Lourdes that cured it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s